Wendy Doniger's ‘The Hindus’ is not a good introduction to the spirituality of Hinduism

SHARE:


If you are drawn to read Wendy Doniger’s The Hindus – as I was – because you see in Hinduism an example of a cultural-spiritual tradition that has managed to keep alive – right into modern times – a view of a sacred universe (sacred time, sacred geography, sacred cosmology, sacred social customs and social roles, sacred geometry and architecture, rites, rituals, and celebrations, etc.) and a robust set of experiential spiritual practices (puja, kirtan, yoga, meditation, etc.) then you are likely to be disappointed by this book.

It is written, as far as I can tell, entirely from within the same western, modern, secular-academic point of view that has largely rejected a sacred vision of the cosmos and that has largely dismissed whatever tried-and-tested systems of spiritual practice we may once have had. Doniger conveys almost none of the spiritual vitality and seems not to recognize any of the practical spiritual knowledge that other writers and teachers show to be embedded in Hindu scriptures. If anything, she belittles these aspects of Hinduism in just that sort of way that modernized people as a group tend, unfortunately, to do, believing themselves to “know better” and to be more “sophisticated” than people who maintain their ancient traditions. So if you are looking for a view of Hinduism that will lead you beyond the limitations of the modern materialistic-mechanistic worldview, this is not the book for you.

Here is just one example: On page 176, Doniger quotes, from the Kaushitaki Upanishad, a description of the sort of experience one might encounter after bodily death that determines the trajectory of one’s soul. This upanishad says that upon dying, one goes to the moon and must answer its question, and that answering correctly or incorrectly is what determines the soul’s next steps. Now, obviously, from a modern, materialistic, rationalistic point of view, this is all silly, superstitious nonsense and so it would be very easy to dismiss it as such. But we should expect more than this kind of knee-jerk, superficial response from a person who holds herself up as a serious scholar. But rather than exploring what these strange (to modern, western ears) ideas and images might refer to in metaphysical terms (for example, I happen to know that there is a strong connection between the moon and the mental faculty in Hindu metaphysics; so this passage from the unpanishad could be a way of saying that the trajectory of the soul after death is dependent on the level of mental development one has attained during bodily life), Doniger takes the easy way out – the way that will find easy acceptance among her readers who hold modern, mechanistic rationalism to be the only valid viewpoint – and treats as silly the idea that “just one final postmortem exam…determines everything” (and then, in a telling footnote, likens this to a British school exam, clearly demonstrating how Doniger misconstrues and minimizes what may be another culture’s rich spiritual wisdom by filtering it though her own referents while maintaining a distant, scholarly, and disdainful stance.) If it ever occurred to Doniger that the people who authored Hindu scriptures were simply far more open to a broader range of (non-physical) experiences than herself (and, by extension, most westernized, modernized people) she never hints at this possibility in her writing. In my opinion, this is a major fault.

For similar reasons, if you are drawn to this book primarily because of its subtitle “An Alternative History,” and are hoping for insight into more primal forms of Hindu spirituality – before the sanitized, homogenized, overly rationalized form of “Hinduism” as so many of us know it today emerged under the influence of Christianity and western colonialism – then you too are likely to be disappointed. True, Doniger does bring out various strands of the Hindu tradition that are often overlooked, but again, not in a way that demonstrates their spiritual vitality. Her aim seems to be to support the modernist agenda that wants to say, “Look – since there are so many seemingly contradictory strands within this religious system, it’s all obviously just a bunch of made-up hooey and has no real truth.” In other words, Doniger presents the “alternative” Hindu tradition as mainly a complicated tangle of “myths” – in the negative sense of that word – that are best left to scholars like herself to figure out and that have no value other than providing a historical record of various peoples’ literary imaginings. I got the feeling that to Doniger, Hinduism is nothing but a huge body of literature waiting to be analyzed.

Really, what this book is about, more than anything else, is Wendy Doniger and her particular interests. Hinduism almost recedes into the background, seemingly serving merely as a stimulus for her to talk about what matters most to her (mainly: women, oppressed groups of people, and animals). Nothing wrong with those interests at all; but the way in which Doniger talks about Hinduism does not seem to come from Hinduism itself. I feel that she has imposed her interests upon Hinduism in an unnatural – and therefore misleading – way. (Also, if you do not share her strong interest in these things, you may find her continual focus on them tedious.)

On the positive side, I did get out of this book an even stronger sense of just how diverse a tradition Hinduism is and how it evolved over time. Many people will present Hinduism from one particular point of view (polytheistic, monotheistic, dualistic, non-dualistic, Vedic, Vedantic, yogic, tantric, philosophical, ritualistic, brahminical, populist, Shaiva, Vaishnava, etc.) as if any one of these points of view is the “true,” “authentic,” “original,” or most comprehensive form of Hinduism. But while Doniger does present a fairly broad spectrum of Hinduism, she does so, as stated above, while missing the inner heart of it all: the spirituality.

In other words, in my opinion, she misses the point.

Written by Greg JS >>

$type=two$count=4$meta=0$rm=0$cat=0$s=0$va=0$t=oot

Name

1965 War,3,66A,2,Aam Aadmi,1,AAP,37,AAP Rift,4,AAPtard,2,Abhishek Manu Singhvi,1,ABP News,1,ABVP,1,Acche Din,3,Achhe Din,2,Acid Attacks,1,Activism,3,Adarsh Liberal,5,Aditi Restaurant,1,Aditya Chaturvedi,5,Advertorial,1,Afghanistan,3,Africa,1,Afzal Guru,1,Agriculture,2,AIADMK,1,AIB Roast,1,Ajmal Kasab,1,Akshay Bhatt,1,Akshay Marathe,4,Akshay Thakre,1,Al Qaeda,2,Alcohol,1,Algeria,1,Alka Gurha,1,Allen George,2,Ambani,1,Amit Shah,2,Amrit Hallan,4,Amrita Rai,1,Analysis,21,Angola,1,Animal Rights,2,Animal Welfare Board of India,1,Aniruddh Chakraborty,1,Anjali Damania,4,Anjana Bhartia,1,Ankit Lal,1,Ankur Baruah,1,Anna Hazare,2,APJ Abdul Kalam,1,App,1,Apsara Iyengar,1,Arab Spring,1,Archived,110,Argentina,1,Argument,32,Arjun Kapoor,1,Arnab Goswami,5,Arpan Mukherjee Das,2,Arpita Biswas,1,Article Review,1,Arun Jaitley,1,Arundhati Roy,1,Arvind Kejriwal,42,Arvind Passey,1,ASEAN,3,Asha Dwarkanath,1,Asha Mirjie,1,Ashutosh,1,Ashutosh Gowarrikar,1,Asia,1,Assam,2,Atal Bihari Vajpayee,1,Atheism,1,AURA,1,Australia,1,Automobile Industry,1,Ayodhya,1,Ayush Verma,1,Babri Masji Demolition,2,Bajrang Dal,1,Balochistan,2,Bangladesh,2,Banking,1,Banned Books,1,Barkha Dutt,1,Beant Singh,1,Beef,5,Beef Ban,3,Beijing,3,Bestiality,1,Bhagat Singh,2,Bhagwad Gita,2,Bhakts,1,Bihar,3,Bizarre,1,BJP,35,Black Money,1,Bodoland,1,Bodos,1,Bollywood,5,Book Review,2,BR Ambedkar,2,Brain Drain,1,Brazil,1,Breaking Bad,1,Bribery,2,BRICS,1,BRP Bhaskar,1,Brundi,1,BSP,1,Buddhism,1,Burhan Wani,1,Burma,1,Business,1,CAG,2,Capital Punishment,1,Capitalism,1,Caste System,7,CBI,2,CBSE,1,CCP,1,CGA,1,Chanakya,1,Chandrajith Bhaskar,1,Charlie Hebdo,3,Chennai,1,Chennai Express,1,Child Abuse,2,Child Rights,1,China,14,Christianity,5,Christians,2,CIA,1,CIC,1,Citylights,1,Civic Sense,3,Civil Liberties,7,Civil Rights,1,Click Bait,1,CNN-IBN,2,Coal Scam,1,ColorsTV,1,Comedy Nights,1,Comics,12,Commentary,37,Communal,10,Communal Harmony,2,Communism,7,Congress,28,Consent,1,Constipation,1,Constitution,7,Construction,1,Contract Labor,1,Controversy,3,Copyright Infringement,1,Corruption,21,Cow,4,Cows,2,CPM,1,Cricket,1,Crime,10,Criminal Candidates,2,Crorepati Candidates,1,Culture,12,Cut to the chase,1,CV Raman,1,Dadri,4,Dalit,3,Daud Ibrahim,1,Death Sentence,1,Debate,2,Decentralisation,1,Deepa Mehta,1,Deepika Padukone,2,Defence,5,Dehradun,1,Delhi,24,Delhi Gangrape,2,Delhi Police,2,Delhi University,2,Democracy,8,Development,7,Digital India,1,Digvijay Singh,3,Dileep Padgaonkar,1,Diplomacy,3,Discipline,1,Discrimination,4,Diversity,4,Divorce Act,1,DMK,1,Documents,1,Domestic Violence,1,Dr Bijoy Bagchi,6,Dr Brook Robinson,1,Dr Munish Kumar Raizada,1,Dr Saumya Ritesh,3,Dr Shelly Dsouza,2,Dr Sukant Khurana,3,Draupadi,1,DRDO,1,Drugs,1,DTC,1,DTPH,1,Earthquake,3,Economy,16,Education,5,Egypt,1,Ekta Rawat,1,Elections,14,English Vinglish,1,Entertainment,5,Environment,3,Equality,6,Ethiopia,1,Europe,1,Explained,1,Exposed,15,Facebook,1,Facts,1,Family,1,Fan Fiction,1,Farmers,7,Favorites,10,FDI,1,Featured,7,Feminism,12,Film Review,3,Finance,1,Focus,6,Food Security Bill,2,Foreign Policy,32,FP,13,France,5,Francois Gautier,1,Freedom,3,Freedom of Speech,4,Friedrich Hayek,1,Fringe,3,Front Page,29,Frontpage,4,Fundamental Rights,1,Gandhi Jayanti,1,Gandhian,1,Gandhis,3,Ganga,1,Gaurav Kumar,1,Gauri Mailekhi,1,Gautam Joshi,1,Gay Rights,5,GDP,2,Geeta,1,Geetika Suicide Case,1,Get Ahead,2,Ghar Vapsi,1,Google,1,Gopal Kanda,1,Gorkhaland,1,Governance,3,Greg JS,1,Guidelines,1,Gujarat,5,Gujarat Riots,5,Gulf,2,Gurmehar Kaur,2,Hadith,2,Hafiz Sayeed,5,Harish Salve,1,Harit Pradesh,1,Harsh Pratap,2,Harshvardhan,1,Hartosh Singh Bal,1,Haryana,2,Hasee Toh Phasee,1,Hate Speech,1,Health,4,Heart Disease,1,Hema Malini,1,Hemant Dubey,4,Highlight,6,Himadrish Suwan,22,Hindi Media,2,Hindu Fringe,5,Hinduism,12,Hindus,12,Hindutva,14,History,11,Homophobia,1,Homosexuality,3,Honor Killing,1,Housing,1,HUJI,1,Human Resource,1,Human Rights,4,Humor,3,Hunger,1,Hurriyat,5,Hyderabad,1,IAC,2,IAEA,1,Ideas,3,Imperialism,1,Incest,1,Independence Day,1,Indian Air Force,1,Indian Army,5,Indian Freedom Movement,2,Indian Media,11,Indian Men,1,Indian Mujaheedin,1,Indian Muslims,1,Indian Navy,3,Indian Ocean,3,Indian Parents,1,Indian Penal Code,1,Indian Police,4,Indian Women,8,Indians,4,IndiaTV,1,Indira Gandhi,1,Indo-China War,1,Indo-Iran,1,Indo-Pacific Region,1,Indo-Pak,7,Indus,1,Industry,1,Infrastructure,3,Inside Voices,1,Insider,4,Intelligence,1,Internet.org,1,IOR,3,IPL,1,Iran,2,Iraq,1,Ishaan Mohan Bagga,43,Ishrat Jahan,1,ISI,3,ISIS,6,Islam,21,Islamic Fundamentalists,4,Islamophobia,2,Israel,2,Issues,8,IT,1,IT Act,1,J&K,7,Jai Dehadrai,1,Jains,1,Jammu,1,Jana Hitwadi,1,Japan,4,Jaswant Singh,1,Jayasankar Ambadi,1,JDU,3,Jihad,4,Jiten Ram Manjhi,1,Jitendra Singh,1,JNU,4,Journalism,4,JP Sundharam,13,JuD,1,Judaism,1,Judges,2,Judiciary,7,Justice,2,Justice Katju,2,Kabul,1,Kamla Nehru Hospital,1,Kandhar,1,Kanu Agrawal,1,Kapil Sharma,1,Kapil Sibal,1,Kapila Hingorani,1,Karan Johar,1,Karan Thapar,1,Karan Tiwari,1,Karavali,1,Kargil War,1,Kartik Dora,1,Kashinath Pandit,6,Kashmir,20,Kashmir Issue,13,Kashmiri Pandits,3,Kashmiris,2,Kerala,2,Kerala Bhavan,1,Keshav Iyengar,2,Khirki Extension,2,Khushwant Singh,1,Kiran Batni,1,Kiran Bedi,2,Kishtwar,1,Kissing,1,KKHH,1,Konkan,1,Koran,5,Kosal,1,Koshika Kejriwal,1,Kothari Brothers,1,KP Nayar,1,Kulbhushan Jadhav,2,Kumar Shyam,1,Kumar Vishwas,1,Kunwar Pranav Singh,1,Kuwait,1,Lalu Prasad,1,Land Acquisition Bill,5,Landslides,1,Language,1,Lavanya Viswanathan,3,Law,13,Law Enforcement,1,Law Ministry,1,Learning English,1,Left Liberals,5,LeT,1,Letters,1,LGBT,5,Liberals,5,Lifehacks,1,Lifestyle,2,Lila Inter-actions,2,LK Advani,1,Lokesh Saxena,1,Lokpal,1,Lokpal Bill,2,Lord Buddha,1,Lord Krishna,1,Lord Ram,1,Love Jihad,1,Madhur Chadha,1,Mahabharat,2,Maharashtra,4,Mahatma Gandhi,3,Mahesh Sharma,1,Make in India,1,Mallika Sarabhai,1,Malnutrition,1,Mani Shankar Aiyyar,2,Manifesto,1,Manish Paul,12,Manish Sisodia,2,Manjhi,1,Manmohan Singh,3,Manohar Lal Khattar,1,Manu,1,Manufacturing,1,Manusmriti,1,Marathwada,1,Maritime,3,Mark Zuckerberg,1,Marriage Act,3,Mayank Gandhi,5,Mayur Jain,1,MCD,2,McDonald,1,MEA,1,Mecca,1,Media,27,Media Review,1,Medical Negligence,1,Meera Bhaynder,1,Mehbooba Mufti,3,Meme,4,Men's Rights,3,Middle-east,2,Migrants,1,Mika Singh,1,Milan Kumar,7,Minorities,1,Misandry,1,Misogyny,8,MMS,1,MNS,1,Moarlity,1,Mohan Bhagwat,2,Mona Singh,1,Morality,9,Mother Teresa,1,Mother Tongue,1,MPs,1,MRA,1,MSG Movie,1,Mulayam Singh,3,Mumbai,4,Municipality,2,Muslim Women,2,Muslims,18,My Story,4,Myanmar,1,Mysore,1,Mythology,2,Nandita Das,1,Nani Palkhivala,1,Narendra Modi,45,Narmada,1,National Security,7,Nationalism,1,Natural Disaster,4,Nature,1,Navbharat Times,1,Navjot Singh Siddhu,1,Nawaz Sharif,3,Naxalism,2,Naxalites,2,NCP,1,NDA,1,NDTV,2,Neha Taneja,1,Nehru,1,Nepal,1,Net Neutrality,1,NGOs,1,NIA,1,Nido Tania,1,Nigeria,2,Nirbhaya,3,Nirmal Baba,1,Nitish Kumar,2,Nobel Prize,1,Non-violence,1,North Korea,2,North-East India,2,Nuclear Bomb,3,Nuclear Power,1,Objectification,1,Oil,5,OLX,1,Olympics,1,On Social Media,1,On TV,2,ONGC,1,Open Letter,17,Opinion,11,Owaisi,1,P Chidambaram,1,Paan,1,Paan Singh Tomar,1,Pakistan,30,Pakistan Army,2,Pakistanis,1,Pappu,1,Parenting,1,Parliament Attack,1,Parsis,2,Partition,1,Passion Crimes,1,PDA,1,PDP,4,Pedophilia,1,Personality,2,Peshawar,1,Petrol,1,Philippines,1,Philosophy,1,PIL,3,POK,2,Police,2,Policy,18,Policy Watch,9,Political,6,Politics,44,Pollution,1,Polyandry,1,Polygamy,1,Poorvanchal,1,Populism,1,Pornography,3,Poverty,8,Prakash Gowda,5,Prakash Sharma,7,Prannoy Roy,1,Prashant Bhushan,11,Pre Poll Survey,1,Pritish Nandy,1,Priyanka Gandhi,1,Prophet Mohammad,2,Psecularism,7,Public Safety,1,Punjab,1,Punjabis,1,Quotes,1,Racism,1,Raghav Gakhar,2,Rahul Gandhi,14,Rahul Sharma,1,Rahul Singh,1,Rajaram Balajee,1,Rajat Sharma,1,Rajdeep Sardesai,1,Rajguru,1,Rakhi Sawant,1,Ram Mandir,1,Ramayan,1,Ramjas College,1,Ranbir Kapoor,1,Ranveer Singh,1,Rape,18,Rashamohan Singh,1,Ravi Kulkarni,2,Ravi Srivastava,1,Ravish Kumar,1,RAW,1,Real Estate,4,Recall,2,Reforms,2,Regional Cancer Center,1,Relationships,1,Reliance,1,Religion,14,Religious Conversion,3,Renaissance,1,Republic,6,Republic Day,1,Research,3,Reservation,3,Review,5,Richa Paul,1,Right Wing,3,Riots,3,Road Rage,1,Road Safety,3,Roads,1,Robert Vadra,1,Rohit Aggarwal,1,Rohit Nigam,1,Rohit Shetty,1,Rohith Vemula,1,RSS,9,RTI,6,Rural,6,Russia,8,S Ravi,1,Sagarika Ghose,1,Sahajanya Balaganesh,2,Sakshi Maharaj,1,Salil Desai,1,Salman Khan,1,Samajwadi Party,3,Sameer Khan,1,Sangeet Som,1,Sanitation,2,Sanjay Joshi,1,Sanjeev Kumar,1,Satire,22,Saudi Arabia,3,Saurashtra,1,Schedule Caste,4,Science,1,Section 377,4,Secularism,10,Sedition,1,Seemandhra,1,Selfie,1,Sensationalism,1,Separatist,9,Sex Ratio,1,Sex Tape,1,Sex-Ed,1,Sexist,10,Sexual Abuse,4,Sexual Harassment,4,Shabana Azmi,1,Shabnam Latiwala,1,Shahrukh Khan,1,Shamim Zakaria,6,Shana Sood,2,Shashi Tharoor,1,Shashwati Goswami,1,Shastras,1,Shefali Vaidya,2,Sheila Dikshit,1,Shias,1,Shimla Accord,1,Shirish Asthana,2,Shiv Sena,2,Shoma Chaudhury,1,Short Takes,1,Shorts,2,Shruti Seth,1,Shweta Gurjar,1,Siddharth Rathod,1,Sidebar,13,Sikh Riots,1,Sikhs,1,Sleazy Reporting,1,Smart Cities,1,Smita Mukerji,1,Snadeal,1,Snoop Gate,1,Social Media,2,Social Responsibility,1,Socialism,3,Societal,12,Society,30,Soft Drinks,1,Somnath Bharti,4,Somu Kumar,1,Sonia Gandhi,5,Sourabh Jyoti Sharma,18,South Africa,1,South Asia,3,South China Sea,2,South Korea,1,South-Indians,1,Soviet Union,1,SP,1,Speech Excerpts,1,Spirituality,1,Spitters,1,Sports,1,SRCC,1,Sreesanth,1,Students,1,Study Abroad,1,Subramanian Swamy,1,Sudheendra Kulkarni,1,Sufis,1,Sukhdev,1,Sumanth G Rao,1,Sumnesh Salodkar,1,Sunanda Pushkar,1,Supreme Court,8,Surya Solanki,2,Sushant Taing,1,Sushma Swaraj,3,Swachh Bharat Abhiyan,1,Swami Vivekananda,1,Swaraj,3,Syria,1,Taiwan,1,Tapas Mohanty,3,Tarun Tejpal,1,Tathagat Khandelwal,3,Taxation,1,Technology,1,Tehelka,1,Telangana,1,Terrorism,26,Thane,1,The Economist,1,The Hindus,1,The Telegraph,1,Third Front,1,Thoughts,8,Tibet,2,Tiger Memon,1,Times Group,1,Times Now,4,Times of India,2,Tina Jindal,1,Traffic Rules,1,Transgender,1,Trending,226,Trends,1,Trina Nileena Banerjee,1,Trolls,1,Twitter,1,Ugly Truth,2,UK,2,UN,1,Unauthorised Colonies,1,Uniform Civil Code,2,UP,1,UPA,9,US,2,USA,7,Uttar Pradesh,5,Uttarakhand,2,V Jaganmohan,1,Vansh Saluja,1,Varun Tangri,1,Ved Pratap Vaidik,1,Ved Pratap Vedik,1,Vedanta,1,VHP,2,Vidya Subrahmaniam,1,Vidyut Kale,5,Vietnam,1,Vijay Goel,1,Vineeta Tiwari,1,Vir Das,1,Virat Kohli,2,Vishesh Kashyap,4,Vitthal Radadiya,1,Vladimir Putin,1,Vote Bank,1,Voter,1,VVIPs,2,Wahhabism,3,War,2,Water,1,Weapons,5,Wendy Doniger,1,Women,14,Women Empowerment,13,Women Safety,12,World,3,World War II,1,WTO,1,Xi Jinping,1,Yakub Memon,2,Yogendra Yadav,10,Yogi Adityanath,1,Zahoor Ahmed Wani,1,Zakir Naik,1,Zimbabwe,1,
ltr
item
Indian Exponent: Wendy Doniger's ‘The Hindus’ is not a good introduction to the spirituality of Hinduism
Wendy Doniger's ‘The Hindus’ is not a good introduction to the spirituality of Hinduism
https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-2G_VO45KPME/VRv3jvubW-I/AAAAAAAABMU/64vDv71zshk/s1600/The-Hindus-Book-Review.jpg
https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-2G_VO45KPME/VRv3jvubW-I/AAAAAAAABMU/64vDv71zshk/s72-c/The-Hindus-Book-Review.jpg
Indian Exponent
http://www.indianexponent.com/2014/02/the-hindus-by-wendy-doniger-book-review.html
http://www.indianexponent.com/
http://www.indianexponent.com/
http://www.indianexponent.com/2014/02/the-hindus-by-wendy-doniger-book-review.html
true
2092170621401459056
UTF-8
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS PREMIUM Please share to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy